The Indifferent Stars Above: The Harrowing Saga of a Donner Party Bride

Content Warning: This section of the guide discusses starvation, cannibalism, and death.

The Indifferent Stars Above captures the extreme challenges of pioneer life, which was full of hardship and omnipresent danger. Daniel James Brown’s narrative illustrates the trials of life on the frontier: the constant threats faced, the challenges of the natural world, and the uncertain circumstances that plagued every step of the journey west.

Life on the frontier was severe and often fatal, with death being a common occurrence that had a ripple effect exacerbated by patriarchal structures. In June 1846, while camped along the Platte River, the Trimble family, traveling with the Donner Party, experienced a raid by a group of Pawnees, an Indigenous tribe, who drove off a large portion of their cattle. To recover the stolen cattle, Edward Trimble confronted the Pawnees. The Pawnees, emerging from the prairie grass, demanded Trimble’s horse, and upon his refusal, they killed him with arrows and rifles. This violent encounter had immediate consequences for Trimble’s pregnant wife and young children. The reality of being widowed on the frontier was a fear that plagued all women; Brown notes, “To be widowed out here on the plains […] was to a large extent—to be rendered instantly dependent on the goodwill of the men around you” (64).