Beneath a Scarlet Sky

1. General Impressions

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

• What were some of the most memorable or intense scenes in the novel? How did those moments shape your understanding of Pino’s world and the horrors of Nazi-occupied Italy? 
• How effective do you think the novel was in blending historical facts with fiction? Did you feel Sullivan’s portrayal of Pino’s experiences was authentic and believable? 
• By the end of the novel, Pino reflects on his role in the war and his decision not to take Leyer’s life. How did his story’s resolution make you feel, and do you think he found a sense of closure?

2. Personal Reflection and Connection

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

• Pino struggles with seeing his actions as either courageous or cowardly. Can you relate to moments when you felt caught between extremes in your own actions or decisions? How did you make peace with these choices?
• The novel explores the complex nature of loyalty, especially when people are forced to make tough decisions under extreme circumstances. Have you ever had to navigate a situation where loyalty to a person or value was tested? How did it impact you? 
• Pino’s view of the world often demonstrates all-or-nothing thinking.